Employment Tribunal of Gibraltar: Amicus Curiae, Contributory Conduct, and Quantum

19/11/2026 The Hon Neil F Costa

ISOLAS LLP Partner Neil Costa represented the Administrator of the Employer’s Insolvency Fund (the ‘Administrator’) in James Alexander McDonough v Manchester 62 FC Limited before the Employment Tribunal of Gibraltar.

The proceedings illustrate an important distinction between participation as amicus curiae on liability and the substantive determination of quantum.

A distinct role in proceedings

The claim concerned unfair dismissal and breach of contract following the termination of the Claimant’s employment as Head Coach of Manchester 62 Football Club for alleged gross misconduct.

The Administrator had been recognised as an interested party potentially affected by any order of the Tribunal.

The Administrator applied for permission to be heard as amicus curiae on liability. Crucially, the Administrator did not dispute liability for unfair dismissal. The Administrator did not seek to adopt or advance the Respondent’s Response, introduce evidence the Respondent failed to adduce, step into the Respondent’s shoes, or advance any positive case that the dismissal was fair.

Instead, participation was expressly limited to submissions of law and the documents already before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal acceded to the application under rule 34 of the Employment Tribunal (Constitution and Procedure) Rules 2016.

The substantive issue: quantum

While the Administrator did not contest liability, the position concerning remedies was different.

The Tribunal permitted the Administrator, as an interested party, to make submissions, and cross-examine the Claimant, on quantum.

The Tribunal’s findings

The Tribunal struck out the Response. Although the Tribunal found the unfair dismissal claim well-founded, it separately considered the Claimant’s contributory conduct and duty to mitigate his loss.

The Tribunal made no finding of misconduct or gross misconduct against the Claimant in determining the unfair dismissal claim.

The Tribunal determined, however, that the Claimant was, in substance, equally at fault with the Respondent for the circumstances giving rise to his dismissal, including his acceptance of past findings of misconduct involving incidents contrary to the Gibraltar Football Association’s code of discipline.

A 50% reduction for contributory conduct was applied to the relevant elements of the award excluding statutory notice pay.

The Tribunal also determined that the Claimant had not reasonably or adequately mitigated his loss of earnings, having regard to his failure to register as unemployed and/or claim unemployment benefit, and his narrow focus on football-related employment opportunities.

Consequently, compensation for loss of earnings was limited to three months following dismissal.

Applying regulations 2(5), 3(4) and 3(6) of the Employment Tribunal (Calculation of Compensation) Regulations 2016, the Tribunal awarded £8,469.20. The separate £33,000 contractual claim against the Respondent employer was adjourned indefinitely with liberty to apply.

The significance

The proceedings demonstrate how an interested party may assist the Tribunal as amicus curiae on liability without disputing the underlying claim and whilst participating substantively in determining the appropriate compensation.

The case highlights the importance of contributory conduct and mitigation of loss in assessing quantum notwithstanding a successful unfair dismissal claim.

The Administrator was represented by Neil Costa.

 

More insights View all news and insights